Register now! Employment Webinar “Tricky sickness issues” (17 June 2021)

Works council: Insufficiently motivated decision of the company

Publication date: 19 April 2018
When does a company have to reveal its motivation for a decision to the works council? Can an insufficiently motivated decision be fixed at the Enterprise Chamber?

corporate governance

The works council’s right to be consulted

The works council (ondernemingsraad, OR) of a company, has the right to be consulted before certain decisions are taken by the management of the company. If the management does not follow the (negative) advice of the works council entirely or partly, the management has to inform in writing the works council of this decision as soon as possible and explain why the advice is derogated from. The works council can appeal the decision at the Enterprise Chamber within one month after the decision was taken. Therefore, an entrepreneur has to wait one month before implementing a decision which differs from the advice of the works council.

Failure to state reasons

A recent decision of the Enterprise Chamber shows how important it is for entrepreneurs’ decisions derogating from the advice of the works council to be sound and well-timed.

What was going on? Svitzer EUROMED B.V., part of Svitzer Group, which, in turn, is part of the logistics giant Maersk Group, requested its works council about an intended decision, where, among other things, the position of warehouse administrator was to disappear. The works council’s advice was negative: the position would be necessary and its disappearance would not yield the claimed savings. Svitzer took the decision nevertheless, while only marginally addressing the works council’s objections.

Thus, the works council claims at the Enterprise Chamber that Svitzer could not have taken its decision reasonably, as Svitzer did not reveal its motivation and improperly addressed the objections of the works council. During the hearing, Svitzer explained that the decision was partly related to the interest of the Maersk Group. At group level, a favourable contract had been concluded by which the savings could be realized that were doubted by the works council, so that there was indeed good reason for the disappearance of the position.

Can Svitzer save the decision by means of this explanation? No, according to the Enterprise Chamber, the entrepreneur has to disclose his motivation to the works council during the employee participation procedure so that the works council can take the motivation into account in its advice. The entrepreneur will have to address the arguments of the works council in its decision at the latest. Therefore, Svitzer cannot confine itself to explaining its decision (in detail) at the Enterprise Chamber. Svitzer has to revoke the contested decision and make reparation for the consequences.

Advice

If your company takes a decision which is based on the interests of the group you are part of, your works council will have to be informed of these interests in time. If you do not (wholly) follow an advice of the works council, you will have to provide a careful motivation as to why the advice is not followed ultimately in the decision. You cannot fix a flawed decision by an additional explanation during the proceedings before the Enterprise Chamber.

More information

Do you have further questions regarding the relationship between an international works council and the works council of a subsidiary or regarding the right to issue advice of your works council? Or would you like to learn whether you are required to set up a works council? Please contact us:

    Share on social media

    • Works Council
    • Corporate law

    Management and Supervision of Legal Entities Act: What are the changes?

    23 June 2021

    On 10 November 2020, the Dutch Senate adopted the bill on the management and supervision of legal entities. This affects all associations and foundations, but, above all, nonprofit organizations. As an officer of a sports club, are you now more likely to be liable? Do you have to meet additional requirements when you are a member of the supervisory board of a school?

    read on
    • Expats
    • Employment law and dismissal

    17 June 2021: Employment Webinar “Tricky sickness issues”

    17 June 2021

    If your employee reports sick, this may raise many difficult questions. What are your reintegration obligations during the sick leave period? What are you allowed to record about your sick employee with regard to the privacy legislation? We answered these and other questions during a webinar. Watch the video!

    read on
    • Works Council
    • Employment law and dismissal

    Works council

    4 May 2021

    Is there already a works council in your company? Are you a member of your company’s works council? What are the advantages of having a works council in your company? Jan Dop and Priscilla C.X. de Leede explain the role of the works council and give an overview of the works council’s most important rights.

    read on
    • Works Council
    • Employment law and dismissal

    Works council in the company: what should you keep in mind?

    11 February 2021

    A works council plays an important role in the company. The works council can block important decisions of the entrepreneur, but can also enable reorganization of the company. What do you need to know about the works council?

    read on
    • Works Council
    • Employment law and dismissal

    Can you change an employment contract unilaterally?

    15 December 2020

    Can the employer change an employment contract unilaterally? Not without good reason. Is the coronavirus crisis a compelling reason? Does it make any difference if you have agreed to a unilateral changes clause?

    read on
    • Works Council

    The works council in times of crisis

    24 April 2020

    The right to be consulted and the right of consent are ‘special powers’ of the works council. The works council has these powers at all times, hence also in times of crisis. Regarding the corona crisis: What are the rights of the works council? When should the works council be involved?

    read on
    • Expats
    • Contracts

    Q&A coronavirus for company owners in the Netherlands

    16 April 2020

    Follow our coronavirus blog. Today, among other things: I no longer have work for my employees, what does the new scheme entail regarding compensation of their wages? What credit options does the government offer?

    read on
    • Works Council
    • Employment law and dismissal

    When am I not allowed to dismiss an employee?

    18 December 2019

    In a number of cases it is prohibited to dismiss an employee. When is that the case? What are the exceptions to this rule?

    read on