Your lawyerJan Dop, LL.M.
Jan Dop assists national and international enterprises in all facets of their day-to-day business operations. He specializes in personnel, real estate and issues involving public authorities. Jan is Head of our Embassy Desk, that serves Embassies, Consulates, diplomats and expats. He has been a lawyer at Russell since 1995, and became a partner in 2011.
t: +31 20 301 55 55
Non-compete clause and non-solicitation clause in temporary contract valid
Non-compete clauses and non-solicitation clauses have to fulfil specific conditions to be valid, especially if they are included in temporary contracts.
Non-compete clause and non-solicitation clause
A non-compete clause prohibits employees for a certain period beyond the term of their employment contract from being directly or indirectly active or involved in a business performing similar activities. A non-solicitation clause is an agreement between employer and employee that prohibits the employee from being active for or having contact with clients and business associates of the employer beyond the term of the employment contract.
Starting point is that a non-compete and non-solicitation clause are not valid in temporary contracts. The reason for this is that it would doubly disadvantage the employee: such a provision obstructs the transition to another job while it is clear from the beginning of the contract that it is just a temporary one. A provision is valid only if it contains the substantial business interests which require such a provision. If the employer has provided reasons but they fail to convince the court, the provision can be declared void retrospectively.
A recent case dealt with two employees of a company that invested in land for third parties. One of the employees had a fixed contract and the other one a temporary contract. Both had terminated their employment contract to jointly start a competing company. Next, they were held to the non-compete and non-solicitation clause. Is that allowed in case of the employee with a temporary contract, too?
The non-compete clause contains that the employee will gain complete insight in the operating method the employer’s market position is based upon, the location where the employer performs activities, and that he will be informed of the employer’s financial position so that a provision is required to protect the employer’s market position. The requirement of a non-solicitation clause is motivated by indicating that the company depends entirely on retaining its clients and business associates. The employees have so much contact with the employer’s clients that the employer has an interest in prohibiting the contact beyond the term of the contract.
Is this sufficient to maintain both provisions? The court decided positively in this question and considered both the non-compete and non-solicitation clause to be valid by taking into consideration that:
- The former employees intend to buy land that the employer wishes to buy too.
- The former employees may disregard opportunities for the company until they can use them for their own company.
- Land investment is a small sector. The new company will therefore have to acquire customers from the existing customers of the former employer.
- The former employees had been in service for a rather short period and were trained by the former employer to work in the sector.
- The two employees were part of the company’s core staff.
Therefore, also the employee with a temporary contract is prohibited from exploiting the competing business, as long as the clauses are effective.
A non-compete clause and a non-solicitation clause may be included in a temporary contract. However, formulating these clauses requires customization, because they have to provide sound reasons. Would you like a non-compete and/or non-solicitation clause drawn up? Or would you like to have existing agreements assessed? We will gladly check to what extent your employment contracts fulfil the statutory requirements. Please contact us:
We process the personal data below with your permission. You can withdraw your permission at any time. For more information please see our Privacy Statement.
Please fill in the form below and we will call you as soon as possible.