Jan Dop

partner

Jan is a specialist in employment law and corporate law

jan.dop@russell.nl
+31 20 301 55 55

Personnel: How to dismiss employees with immediate effect?

Publication date 24 January 2017

When can you dismiss an employee with immediate effect? How do you do this? And what happens if the employee challenges the dismissal?

vertrekregeling-weblijst.c02219

Termination of employment contract

Employers can terminate employment contracts in different ways:

  • Upon permission from the UWV (Employee Insurance Agency) because of commercial reasons or long-term disability
  • Via a request for termination submitted to the subdistrict court because of any of the other reasons
  • By mutual consent
  • Termination during the trial period, and
  • Via dismissal with immediate effect.

Conditions for dismissal with immediate effect

For dismissal with immediate effect there must be an urgent cause. The dismissal must take place immediately, with immediate notification of the urgent cause.

Urgent cause

The employer can dismiss an employee with immediate effect – without observing the applicable notice period – if there is an urgent cause. Examples of urgent causes include, for instance, theft of property of the employer or acts of violence. In certain cases, use of alcohol can also form an urgent reason.

Immediate termination

Instant dismissal must be effected immediately. This means, after the discovery of the urgent cause the employee must be dismissed as quickly as possible. The dismissal can be effected several days after the discovery of the urgent cause, if it can be established that this period was necessary for the investigation of the urgent cause, hearing the employee, internal consultations or seeking legal advice.

Immediate notification

The dismissal must be effected with immediate notification of the underlying urgent cause. The employer must let the employee know as soon as possibly why he is dismissed. This is usually done by sending a detailed written motivation to the employee after the dismissal has been communicated orally.

Ultimate remedy

Dismissal with immediate effect can have far-reaching consequences for the employee. He will not only lose his job, but also his entitlement to transitional compensation and unemployment benefits. Dismissal with immediate effect is therefore also called an “ultimate remedy”, which will only be justified in serious cases.

What does the court consider?

Because of the far-reaching consequences, the dismissal is often challenged by the employee. The employee can challenge the dismissal with immediate effect by requesting the subdistrict court to declare void the dismissal within two months after the dismissal.

In potential proceedings the court will consider whether there is an urgent cause and whether the dismissal was effected immediately and with immediate notification of the urgent cause. In addition, the circumstances of the case will be considered, such as:

  • The length of the employment
  • The functioning of the employee during the employment
  • The age of the employee, and
  • The consequences of the dismissal for the employee.

Proceedings on dismissal with immediate effect can take a long time, which creates an uncertain situation for the employer. In fact, the court can even declare void the dismissal just like that after years of legal proceedings. The employer then has to readmit the employer to his activities when his former position has been taken by a new employee. So it is useful to terminate the employment contract conditionally.

More information

Do you need advice on dismissal of an employee with immediate effect? Or is a dismissal you effected challenged by the employee? Please contact us:

    We process the personal data above with your permission. You can withdraw your permission at any time. For more information please see our Privacy Statement.

    Related publications

    Dismissal on the spot for a minor offence. Is that allowed?

    Can you dismiss your employee with immediate effect after the theft of a (very) low-value product? Yes, you can! However, a recently published decision shows it does not go without a risk!

    Read more

    Statutory director: the good, the bad and the other leaver

    On the departure of a statutory director/shareholder, any participation in the company must also be settled. Then a discussion may arise about the value of this participation, depending on whether the director counts as a good leaver or bad leaver. What should companies and directors pay attention to when interpreting a leaver arrangement?

    Read more

    The resolutive condition in an employment contract

    An employer can include a resolutive condition in the employment contract. However, this can only be done in exceptional cases. What requirements must a resolutive condition meet? Is the employee entitled to transitional compensation when the resolutive condition takes effect?

    Read more

    Legislative proposal on reform of non-competition clauses

    The government has detailed its plans for tightening non-competition clauses in a legislative proposal. What are the proposed conditions for valid reliance on a non-competition clause? How will the proposal affect existing clauses?

    Read more

    Annual checklist: does your works council tick all 10 boxes?

    How is your works council performing this year? As a works council, do you have many requests for advice and consent? Do the legally required consultation meetings with the company take place? Use our brief checklist to assess your cooperation with the company.

    Read more

    Jurisprudence concerning statutory directors, July-December 2023

    Disputes between statutory directors and employers are regularly dealt with in courts. The following is an overview of some relevant judgments on the legal position of statutory directors in the period July-December 2023.

    Read more